| Gender Equality Digest | |
| << back to list screen | |
| Full Case Record | |
| ID | 117 |
| Case | R v Ahluwalia |
| TypeofCase | Murder or manslaughter |
| Summary | Kiranjit Ahluwalia entered into an arranged marriage and suffered years of abuse from her husband. In May 1989 she threw petrol into his bedroom and set it alight. Her husband died six days later of his burns. She was convicted of murder on 7 December 1989 and appealed against her conviction. The first ground of appeal was that the judge wrongly directed the jury that a plea of provocation depended on establishing a ‘sudden’ loss of self-control; the second was that he failed to take into account that the defendant was suffering from ‘battered woman syndrome’, producing a state of ‘learnt helplessness’. The successful ground of appeal was the third. Medical evidence available but not used at the first trial showed that the defendant was suffering from a major depressive disorder; this could have provided the basis for a successful plea of diminished responsibility. The conviction was quashed and a retrial ordered. Comment: the case has wider significance in relation to the use of provocation pleas based on battered woman syndrome, and the seeming tendency to prefer a plea of diminished responsibility where a woman is involved. Despite the role of Southall Black Sisters in bringing this case to appeal, cultural issues play no explicit part in the judgement. But where the direction at the original trial tended to minimise the vulnerability of the defendant, the judgement at the Court of Appeal stressed her physical slightness, state of humiliation, and loss of self-esteem, and noted that she remained in an abusive marriage because of her ‘sense of duty as a wife’. |
| Year | 1992 |
| Citation | [1992] 4 All ER 889 |
| Court | Court of Appeal |
| RelatedCases | R v Kiranjit Ahluwalia, 1989 |
| Judge | Taylor (The Lord Chief Justice), Swinton Thomas, Judge |